About Overwater Grill Menu Overwater Grill Weekly Special Overwater Grill Events Overwater Grill Photo Gallery
Menu
- Appetizers
- Sandwiches & Wraps
- Sides
- Baskets
- Raw Bar
- Soups & Salads
- Something Sweet
- Poke Bowls
- Burgers
Appetizers
-
Steamed Mussels
One pound of farm-raised mussels sautéed in wine sauce, onions, garlic, and tomatoes, sprinkled with parmesan cheese
$13.99
-
Baja Fish Tacos
Two crunchy corn taco shells loaded with our crunchy fried fish, shredded cabbage, chili tequila lime sauce, and pico de gallo served with our chipotle crème sauce
$9.99
-
Honey Ribs
Flash-fried St. Louis ribs glazed with honey sriracha, topped with green onions and sesame seeds
$13.99
-
Fried Chicken Livers
Lightly breaded and deep-fried, served with our spicy honey mustard sauce
$9.99
-
Cajun Bacon-Wrapped Scallops
A house favorite! Three large sea scallops wrapped with bacon and grilled to perfection with our honey lime sauce
$18.99
-
Coconut Shrimp
Premium shrimp dipped in coconut batter, rolled in shredded coconut, then deep-fried. Served with island dipping sauce
$12.99
-
Crunchy Chicken Tenders
Fresh chicken tenders, cornflake breaded, then golden fried
$8.99
-
Conch Fritters
Loaded with conch (konk), served with Bahamian fritter sauce
$10.99
-
Seared Yellowfin Tuna*
Sushi-grade tuna served with wasabi, soy, and ginger
$14.99
-
Blue Cheese & Balsamic Tater Chips
House-made potato chips covered with melted bleu cheese fondue and finished with balsamic glaze, tomatoes, and green onions
$16.99
-
Bacon-Wrapped Plantains
With orange chipotle glaze
$8.99
-
Popcorn Chicken Bites
Fried, Asian-seasoned chicken bites served over popcorn, drizzled with your choice of key lime habanero or Sriracha honey
$11.99
-
Jumbo Chicken Wings, Mon!
Lightly breaded, deep-fried, and tossed in your choice of sauce: key lime habanero, garlic teriyaki, bourbon BBQ, Sriracha Honey, or Jamaican jerk BBQ sauce
$13.99
Bleu cheese & celery $0.99 per +
Extra Sauce $0.50 per +
-
Fried Calamari
Fresh calamari coated in seasoned flour, then deep-fried
$15.99
-
Queso Cheese Dip
Served with tri-color corn chips
$9.99
Shrimp Queso $14.99
-
Crunchy Fish Fingers
Fresh fish strips rolled in cornflakes, then deep-fried golden brown
$8.99
-
Smoked Fish Dip
Mild fish blend smoked then blended to create a taste sensation. Includes diced tomato, onion, and jalapeño on request
$12.99
-
Ahi Tuna Tartar*
Sashimi-grade yellowfin tuna diced and mixed with sweet Thai chili and sriracha. Garnished with green onions and wasabi cream sauce. Served over potato chips
$16.99
Sandwiches & Wraps
Most items are served with lettuce, tomato, onion, and chips. Add fries $1.99 Choice of honey lime, Jamaican jerk, garlic teriyaki, or apricot ginger lime on grilled item. American, Swiss, cheddar, provolone, pepper jack, bacon, sautéed onion or bleu cheese add $1.75 Gluten Free bun add $1.49
-
Oak Grilled Fish Sandwiches
With your choice of baste or sauce
Mahi $16.99
Tuna $16.99
Grouper $19.99
-
Lobster-N-Crab Cake
Our special blend of lobster and crab meat fried or sautéed
$18.99
-
Pineapple & Teriyaki Mahi Sandwich
Oak-grilled mahi and pineapple with teriyaki glaze and citrus mayo
$17.99
Substitute Chicken $14.99
-
Crunchy Fish or Chicken BLT Wrap
Your choice of crunchy fish or chicken, smoked bacon, fresh ripe tomatoes, and iceberg lettuce tossed with our Cajun mayo and wrapped in a seasoned herb wrap
$13.99
-
Crunchy Fish Sandwich
Mild fish fillet dusted in seasoned flour, rolled in cornflakes, then deep-fried
$12.99
-
Abaco Fish Sandwich
Coconut-fried fish fillet topped with mango chutney and smothered with melted Swiss cheese
$12.99
-
Cuban Sandwich
Mojo-marinated fresh pork, baked ham, genoa salami, imported Swiss, dill pickle, and yellow mustard on fresh-pressed Cuban bread
$13.99
-
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Chicken breast fried and coated with key lime habanero sauce
$13.99
-
Buffalo Wrap
Your choice of shrimp or chicken coated with our key lime habanero sauce and wrapped together with our bleu cheese slaw
$12.99
-
Shrimp Caesar Wrap
Oak-grilled shrimp tossed with parmesan cheese, romaine lettuce, and our key lime caesar dressing
$13.99
Sides
-
French Fries
$3.99
-
Cole Slaw
$2.99
Baskets
Served with French fries and slaw-
Fried Shrimp Basket
Plump shrimp fried to perfection!
$14.99
-
Chix-N-Chips
Crunchy fried chicken tenders
$12.99
-
Fried Clam Basket
Our lightly seasoned, single-breaded, deep-fried clam strips
$13.99
-
Fish-N-Chips
Fresh fish nuggets dusted in seasoned flour, then deep-fried to a golden brown
$13.99
Raw Bar
-
Clams Raw* or Steamed
Full dozen $10.99
-
U-Peel Shrimp
14 hot or chilled
$12.99
-
Oysters*
When available
Dozen $19.99
Soups & Salads
-
Joe's Conchy Chowder
Cup $5.99
Bowl $8.99
-
Caesar Salad
Fresh romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese tossed in our key lime Caesar dressing and topped with seasoned croutons
$12.99
-
Garden Salad
Fresh-cut lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, carrot, and red cabbage. Served with our homemade orange balsamic vinaigrette dressing
$11.99
-
Our Salad
Baby greens, tomato, red onion, white raisins, candied pecans, and dried cranberries, lightly tossed in our signature vanilla vinaigrette dressing and topped with bleu cheese crumbles
$13.99
-
Grilled Shrimp Skewer on Any Salad Add
$6.99
-
Grilled Mahi-Mahi on Any Salad Add
$9.99
-
Grilled Tuna on Any Salad Add
$10.99
-
Grilled Chicken on Any Salad Add
$5.99
Something Sweet
-
Mike's Key Lime Pie
Slice $7.99
-
Chocolate Seduction Cake
$7.99
-
House-Made Banana Pudding
$5.99
Poke Bowls
All come with cucumber, carrots, sesame seeds and green onions. Served over coconut rice $13.99-
Shrimp
Chilled shrimp with sweet Thai chili and wasabi cream sauce
-
Tuna
Chilled sushi-grade tuna with spicy sauce
-
Thai Chicken
Grilled chicken breast, pineapple, crunchy fried onions, and peanut sauce
-
Teriyaki Chicken
Grilled chicken, pineapple, and teriyaki sauce
-
Stuffed Sweet Potato
Jumbo sweet potato stuffed with pulled pork, green onions, and topped with bourbon BBQ sauce
$12.99
-
Drunken Sweet Potato (Sebastian)
A house favorite! This ain't your ordinary, small sweet potato! Brown sugar, MYERS's Dark Jamaican rum, and special tropical spices
$6.99
Burgers
Oakwood Grilled Half-Pound Burgers
Served with chips. add fries $1.99, add cheese $1.75, gluten free bun add $1.49-
Basic Burger
$13.99
-
Overwater Grill Burger
Cajun bacon and melted bleu cheese
$16.99
-
Bourbon Burger
Grilled onions, pepper jack cheese, pickled jalapeños, crunchy fried onions, and bourbon BBQ
$15.99
-
Hawaiian Burger
Grilled pineapple slice, crunchy fried onions, and our teriyaki glaze
$15.99
-
Veggie Burger
$12.99
-
Lobster & Crab Burger
Our burger topped with a lobster crab cake. Bring your banker!
$19.99
-
Kid's Cheese Burger
12 years old & under
$5.99
Specialty Stacked Burgers
Half- Pound Angus, no substitutions please. Served with chips. add fries $1.99, add cheese $1.75, gluten free bun add $1.49-
Burger #1
Pepper jack cheese, jalapeños, pico de gallo salsa, tricolor corn chips, chipotle cream, and melted queso cheese sauce
$17.99
-
Burger #2
Bacon, bleu cheese, sautéed red onion jam, homemade potato chips, and balsamic glaze
$18.99
-
Burger #3
Swiss cheese, dill pickle, tomato slice, French fries, sautéed red onion jam, and Bahamian fritter sauce
$17.99